Skip to content

How to incorporate operational interruptions ...

Billy HuiMember for 21 years 11 months
Created
6
4
0
How to incorporate operational interruptions into construction scheduling ( MS Project and P3) ?

Operational interruptions means those prescheduled or probabilistic events such as holidays or breaks as set in resource/activity calendars (involving multiple resource calendars), equipment breakdowns (updating progressed schedule) or any environmental delays etc.


Best regards,

Billy Hui

6 replies

Oldest first
  1. 0
    Billy Hui ·
    Maybe I ask in another way.

    Would anyone give me some ideas on "Operational interruptions can be modeled using resource calendars or probability distributions for productive hours/day, depending on weather patterns" ?


    Best regards,

    Billy
  2. 0
    Erik Jonker ·
    Hi Billy,

    For holidays/ Rain days use your calender.
    If a breakdown is your whole plant, you can use your calender.

    If an interuption is only specific to a activity/ group of activities, I do the following:

    Create an activity describing the breakdown. Link it with a FF and a lag equal to the successor remaining duration.

    This should clearly indicate the delays.

    Cheers
  3. 0
    Billy Hui ·
    Thanks for Erik’s reply.

    Let’s further consider an example.

    Activity Y is resource dependent and needs resources Eng1
    and Eng2. And this activity needs 5 days to complete the
    activity. Eng1 would not be available on day 2 & 3 and Eng2 would not be available on day 3 & 4. As a result, the original duration of the activity would change to 7 days after scheduling. The following figure would show the situation. X means holiday and both resources will work 5 days to complete the activity.

    1234567
    -XX---- Eng1
    --XX--- Eng2

    How can I get 8 days as a solution ?

    12345678
    -XX#---- Eng1
    -#XX---- Eng2

    #: Activity Y can not proceed without both Eng1 & Eng2 exist.
  4. 0
    Billy Hui ·
    A better version :

    ......would change to 7 days after scheduling. The following figure would show the situation. X means holiday and both resources will work 5 days to complete the activity.

    1234567
    oXXoooo Eng1
    ooXXooo Eng2

    o: task working or business day.

    How can I get 8 days as a solution ?

    12345678
    oXX#oooo Eng1
    o#XXoooo Eng2

    #: Activity Y can not proceed without both Eng1 & Eng2 exist.
  5. 0
    Erik Jonker ·
    Billy ,

    If you have to mangage your whole project at such a level, MS-Project is not your answer. Try P3 or a package that processes resources in the same way.

    See my other posting for P3 http://www.planningplanet.com/forum/forum_post.asp?Cat=2&Top=6990

    Other wise use a spreadsheet to interface your critical critical resources.

    You just can’t do something like this with MS-Projects.

    Regards,

    Erik
  6. 0
    Billy Hui ·
    Erik,

    Thanks for your help.

    Regards,

    Billy.

Log in or join to reply

ProjectControls.com is free to join. Members can post questions, reply, vote and follow discussions.

Existing members: your original username and password still work. Forgot password?