Skip to content

Negative Float on Milestone?

Victoria TanMember for 18 years 7 months
Created
12
4
0
Hi Guys,
I have a milestone in my P5 schedule which finish date is correct as planned. However, the milestones and all of its predecessors (20#) are showing negative float, while all of its successors are showing positive float.

There are no constraints in the logic path, no must finish by date on the project, and I am scheduling using progress override.

Any ideas please?
Vicky

12 replies

Oldest first
  1. 0
    Oliver Melling ·
    Double check that you don’t have any constraints on the milestone?
  2. 0
    Victoria Tan ·
    Checked already Oliver.

    I’m tearing my hair out here...

    Please anyone? I’m fairly new to P5 but have not come across this in P3 before.

    Thanks
    Vicky

  3. 0
    Oliver Melling ·
    Try pressing F5 to refresh the data as someone on the same database might have added something whilst you’ve working.
  4. 0
    Victoria Tan ·
    Thanks again Oliver,

    I am using P5 as Standalone.

    Any other suggestions?

    Cheers
    Vicky
  5. 0
    Anoon Iimos ·
    is it a finish milestone or a start milestone?
  6. 0
    Victoria Tan ·
    Hi Anoon,

    It is a start milestone.

    Cheers
    Vicky
  7. 0
    Anoon Iimos ·
    i’m sure there are invalid relationships as well in the schedule log, try changing it to finish milestone and see what happens, or you can add another milestone (in this case you need to change the logic).
  8. 0
    Satya Narayana ·
    check if some actual date was entered in any of the activity
  9. 0
    Victoria Tan ·
    Hi Sat,

    Yes some predecessors have actual dates but I am using progress override?

    I changed milestone to finish but float still the same.

    Looks like a long nite for me...boss said negative float cannot lah! :-)

    Cheers
    Vicky
  10. 0
    Satya Narayana ·
    Thats really tricky
  11. 0
    David Podmore ·
    Hi Victoria,

    Still having probs? I have found that on very rare occasions that some actual data once entered and then removed (for whatever reason) can remain in the database despite appearing not to. If the job is not too onerous I would be tempted to make an XER of where you are now so you can go back and then take off progress, task by task, up the logic stream, recalculating after each. You may find the oddity this way.
    If you do find it, note the task details and delete it. Add it back in as before and retrace the progress back to now. A hassle but no one said detective work is easy...

    David
  12. 0
    Ronald Winter ·
    Look for external relationships to activities outside of your current schedule. Add the Projects column to your relationship tabs. This may show you something. Good luck!

Log in or join to reply

ProjectControls.com is free to join. Members can post questions, reply, vote and follow discussions.

Existing members: your original username and password still work. Forgot password?