Skip to content

P6.1; WBS Total Original Duration Problem

Abeer MahmoudMember for 18 years 3 months
Created
7
2
0
WBS title is Item #1 (included Activity #1 & 2)
1.Activity #1; Total Float =0 and original duration is (8days) start 04-May-10 (8:00) finish 12-May-10 (16:00)
2.Activity #2 will start after finish activity #1; Total Float = 33 and original duration is (1days) start 13-May-10 (8:00) finish 13-May-10 (16:00)

After run schedule I found the following:
WBS title is Item #1, Total Float = 27 instead of 33 and original duration is 8days instead of 9days start 04-May-10 (8:00) finish 13-May-10 (16:00)

I wonder why this conflict happened.

Please advise by steps.
Best Regards,
Abeer

7 replies

Oldest first
  1. 0
    Deepak Jain ·
    The WBS duration is not a sum of the durations but a calculation based on the start and finish activities on the default calendar.
  2. 0
    Abeer Mahmoud ·
    Dear Deepak,
    Kindly note that the two activities have the same calendar,
    So WBS total duration must be the sum of activities durations which = 9days not 8days

    Regards,
    Abeer
  3. 0
    A D ·
    Check Global Calendar

    WBS total Duration is calculated using Global Calendar and NOT using activity calendar.

    This is still a enhancement request.
  4. 0
    Abeer Mahmoud ·
    Thanks Raviraj,

    You are right global calendar was 5 working days because most of rest WBS activities have the same working days and the mention below WBS activities is 6 working days.
    But when I changed global calendar to 6 working days I found the following:
    WBS title is Item #1, original duration was corrected to 9days instead of 8days
    Other WBS’s sum durations increased from 1 to 3 days which is not correct for example WBS #2 included 2 activities with 5 working days;
    -Activity #3; duration is (11days) start 06-May-10 (8:00) finish 20-May-10 (16:00)
    -Activity #4 will start after finish activity #3; original duration is (1days) start 23-May-10 (8:00) finish 23-May-10 (16:00)
    But WBS #2 sum duration = 15days instead of 12days.
    So if I have many calendars at the same project what is the global calendar I must assign to make the schedule WBS’s sum durations is right and reasonable.
    Regards,
    Abeer
  5. 0
    Rodel Marasigan ·
    Abeer,

    Click the link below where I explained the proper use of Multiple Calendar
    Multiple calendar scheduling Post #3
  6. 0
    A D ·
    Hi Abeer,

    From Rodel’s link, things might b very clear for u.

    Here’s a workaround to overcome WBS bars problem:

    - Set the rolled up totals OFF in Group and sort

    - Add an LOE, OR

    - Add WBS summary activity with the calendar you want to use for calculating the summary duration.

    Cheers,
  7. 0
    A D ·
    Some more links

    http://primavera.zxlm.cn/kb/prim84057

Log in or join to reply

ProjectControls.com is free to join. Members can post questions, reply, vote and follow discussions.

Existing members: your original username and password still work. Forgot password?