Skip to content

Constraints in P6

John DrokovicMember for 17 years
Created
4
2
0

I'd like to ask the experienced guys using constraints in their schedules / programmes as to what is the difference by using the different constraint types.

Start Constraints

- As Late As Possible

- Mandatory Start

- Start On

- Start On or Before

- Start On or After

Finish Constraints 

- As Late As Possible

- Mandatory FInish

- Finish On

- Finish On or Before

- Finish On or After

4 replies

Oldest first
  1. 0
    Mike Testro ·

    Hi John The correct answer is

    Hi John

    The correct answer is never use any of them as they distort the logic of the programme.

    There is a case to use ALAP on third party milestones such as Power On and delivery of Free Issue Materials.

    Also "must start on" for the very first activity milestone otherwise none at all.

    Best regards

    Mike Testro

  2. 0
    Gary Whitehead ·

    John,   Go to the help menu

    John,

     

    Go to the help menu of primavera and search for "constraints". It will give you a good definition of what the effects of each type are are.

     

    However in summary:

     

    -"Start" types affect start dates, and "finish" types affect finish dates

    -"On or before" types affect late dates, and "On or after" types affect early dates

    -"On" types affect both early and late dates

    -"Mandatory" types will ignore logic to maintain the mandatory date, and calculate total float for preceding activities based on this mandatory date

    -"ALAP" pushes an activity out as late as possible without delaying any sucessors (ie zero free float)

  3. 0
    Ryan Lytollis ·

    Mike is right, never use

    Mike is right, never use them, And if you have to I would limit it to between 5 - 10% of all activities.
  4. 0
    Rafael Davila ·

    Be aware some software are

    Be aware some software are particularly bad at handling multiple constraints, at times yielding erroneous results.

    http://www.planningplanet.com/forums/primavera-version-pm5-pm6/517280/primavera-p3-and-suretrak-wrong-dates-under-multiple-constra

Log in or join to reply

ProjectControls.com is free to join. Members can post questions, reply, vote and follow discussions.

Existing members: your original username and password still work. Forgot password?