Skip to content

Resource loading challenge

Martin CorkillMember for 23 years 3 months
Created
5
4
0

Here's the challenge...

You have 10 activities in your schedule.  They are all resource loading (not necessarily the same resources).  They have a 'prioritisation' code allocated to determine the sequence of preference for resource levelling.  There are no real inter-dependencies between them.  They can all happen in any order, they could all happen at the same time, apart from 1 of those activities (let's call it Activity X).  When Activity X happens, none of the other 9 can be planned to happen.  How can this be achieved using resource loading?

 


 

5 replies

Oldest first
  1. 0
    Rafael Davila ·

    Create a marker resource say

    • Create a marker resource say Resource A with availability of 9 ea.
    • Assign 1 ea to the 9 activities that can happen at the same time.  If you want to set some prioritization do it.  A good resource leveling engine will respect the prioritization as long as it can yield shorter schedule duration.
    • Assign 9 ea to the activity that cannot happen while the other 9 activities.
    • Resource level. Check resource leveling by moving some activities to see if the requirement for Activity X holds after leveling.

    If using effort hours translate availability and assignments to how your software works.

    Challenge2018.08.22

  2. 0
    Martin Corkill ·

    Rafael - thanks, that's a

    Rafael - thanks, that's a useful suggestion.  I'll give it a go.  Obviously the numbers are higher, but the logic behind what you are suggesting should still work, if I create a resource with a limit of 5000 (being silly), assign 1 to each activity that can happen whenever, and 5000 to the one that can only happen on it's own.

  3. 0
    Johannes Vandenberg ·

    Hi MartinI have modeled the

    Hi Martin

    I have modeled the challenge in Primavera P6.

    Resource optimization is finding the balance between the resource requirements and the resource availability.

    The resource requirements you detail in the activity

    The resource availability you detail in the enterprise> resources

    In this case, I have 10 times 8 hours/day=80 hours/day requirement

    I have detailed 9 times 8 hours/day=72 hours/day availability.

    I leveled the resources and the result you see below.

    Thrust this is clear 

    Regards

    Johannes

    Simple, Free Image and File Hosting at MediaFire

  4. 0
    Rafael Davila ·

    Please be reminded that

    Please be reminded that leveling effort hours is not the same as leveling resource quantity.  It might seem equivalent but under partial workloads leveling of effort might yield wrong results.

  5. 0
    Raymund de Laza ·

    Johanness presentation below

    Johanness presentation below is the right procedure. This can be applied too using Quantities of Workloads.

Log in or join to reply

ProjectControls.com is free to join. Members can post questions, reply, vote and follow discussions.

Existing members: your original username and password still work. Forgot password?