Skip to content

Effect of NLT constraint

Evgeny Z.Member for 18 years 9 months
Created
2
2
0

Hi,

I was playing with priorities and found the following effect, which I can’t logically explain.

Just wondering whether it “works as designed” and id "yes", then what is the reason for it?

Effect description

Rule 1. Any activity, which has in it’s successor’s chain an activity with NLT restriction, always has a higher priority, than activity, which has no NLT restriction in it’s successor’s chain, regardless of it’s priority or priority of the phases above it.  This is even in the situation, when NLT restriction is far enough not to be taken into account.

Rule 2. Out of 2 activities, both of which have NLT restriction in their successor’s chain, the activity where NLT restriction is set to earlier date has a higher priority regardless of it’s priority or priority of the phases above it.. This is even in the situation, when NLT restriction is far enough not to be taken into account.

 

In the example below one can see, that following activity priorities Phase 1 shall have highest priority, Phase 2 middle, and Phase 3 lowest.

But because Phase 1 does not have NLT constraint, in reality it has lowest priority.

Out of Phase 2 and Phase 3, Phase 3 has the earliest NLT constant date (even though it is still 1 year from the now), therefore it gets higher priority, than Phase 2.

 

The SpiderProject file is available in the Google Drive link below

https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B1FBt_G3gCVqaS1jRHNjOHk4bFE/edit

 photo EffectofNLTconstraint_zpsef102a63.png

2 replies

Oldest first
  1. 0
    Rafael Davila ·

    I was expecting for finish

    I was expecting for finish constraints to be considered only when already broken or when leveling algorithm breaks them otherwise no, no matter how close.

  2. 0
    Vladimir Liberzon ·

    Rafael,you are right. It

    Rafael,

    you are right. It looks like something went wrong and we will check it later.

Log in or join to reply

ProjectControls.com is free to join. Members can post questions, reply, vote and follow discussions.

Existing members: your original username and password still work. Forgot password?