Skip to content

Summation Error

Amanullah MughalMember for 21 years 10 months
Created
6
1
0
Dear Planners,

I am user of P6; and facing a problem. Please share your experience to resolve this problem stated below:

Suppose there are 5 activities under one WBS with different durations having FS relationship. The total duration starting from Ist activity to early finish of last activity comes out 50 days; but when I rollup on WBS level, it shows 34.

Anyone can help me out of the situation.

Aman

6 replies

Oldest first
  1. 0
    David Kelly ·
    In P6 all summary durations, for all projects for all sub-totals (e.g. each WBS) as well as the total project duration are calculated the same way.

    The duration is set as the number of workperiods between the start and finish dates on the database’s default calander.

    So in your example the database default calendar is NOT the same as the calendar on your activities.

    SOLUTION

    Set the rolled up totals OFF in "Group and sort"

    Add an Loe OR WBS summary activity with the calendar you want to use for calculating the summary duration.
  2. 0
    K D ·
    Hi.
    Or you can set the default calendar same as activity calendar.
  3. 0
    Naveen Subbaiah ·
    hi,

    that won’t help if you have different calendars for different activities. This concern has been raised on more than one occasion directly to Primavera CEO during middle east annual primavera conference & we have not got any response on this. So the best way to avoid confusion is to hide the summary durations.

    Regards
    Naveen
  4. 0
    Andrew Dick ·
    Guys,
    This problem is as a result of the global calendars and default units per time period, combined with resource and activity calendars.

    Basically Primaveras standard line is "that’s how the software was designed"

    I have written a small technical paper/benchmark to try and illeviate this error, drop me a line at andrewtdick@hotmail.com and I’ll send you a copy.

    Have a look at it and tell me what you think.

    The downside is that you may loose some enterprise functionality as advertised by Primavera, but at the end of the day we just need the K.I.S.S. principle and not all the bells and whistles that they have tried to give us.


    Andy
  5. 0
    K D ·
    Hi Andrew.
    Could you send me that technical paper?

    Thanks & regards
  6. 0
    K D ·
    Hi.
    PowerProject software can solve this problem.
    This is the typical feature which I think PowerProject is stronger than Primavera.

Log in or join to reply

ProjectControls.com is free to join. Members can post questions, reply, vote and follow discussions.

Existing members: your original username and password still work. Forgot password?